• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Welcome to Crostini Sandwiches

At Crostini Sandwiches, every bite tells a story of flavor and community. Nestled in the heart of Madison, Wisconsin, our eatery specializes in gluten-free sandwiches and hearty salads that celebrate bold ingredients. With favorites like the Philly Cheesesteak and classic Cheeseburger, we prioritize quality and taste. Our welcoming atmosphere caters to families, friends, and anyone in search of a casual yet classy dining experience. We pride ourselves on swift service, whether you choose to dine in or take out. Join us for a delightful meal in our cozy space, where every dish is crafted to satisfy and elevate your palate.

Crostini Sandwiches: Reviews & Ratings

Patti T.
Patti T.

We placed an order for pickup including a sub sandwich, a panini, and fries. Everything was ready in advance of our pickup time which worked out great for us. The online ordering system is a little clunky but they were able to handle our requests (no tomato). And the ability to see your order status was very nice. Our food was still hot (that should be) when we picked up. The actual restaurant is a little awkward when you get inside. There's a small alcove to the left where you place your order. And you have to ring the bell for service. Everyone was super nice and the place looked vibey from what I could see. Not a ton to say since I just picked up. The food was excellent. The sub sandwich comes rolled kind of like a wrap which I wasn't expecting but didn't impact the flavor of experience. The panini was huge and easily 2 meals. Fries were soooo good. Like stadium quality. And don't skip the nacho cheese if you like a classic cheese fry. Overall I'm sad we haven't tried them sooner!

Nancy D.
Nancy D.

I love this place in my neighborhood and always get the Italian beef. The people are friendly. The ambience is comfortable. Another little Northside treasure IMO.

Don W.
Don W.

Awesome service and a great sandwich! Set me up with dinner before my flight back to Dallas.

Jetrin P.
Jetrin P.

Went in there for a quick bite, ordered a steak sandwich with all the works and fries. It took about 10-15 minutes and I was the only one in the restaurant. The place has a real cozy atmosphere feel to it with arcade games at the back and vibrant decorations that makes the place feel like a retro diner sorta. When the food came out it was in a basket (guess I forgot to order to-go) and the fries were fresh out the oil. Generous portion of fries and the sandwich was thick with meat. I'm not playing, its a pretty big sandwich! Food could be enough for 2 if you're not a big eater. Yummy lunch would definitely come here to try more items. Paid a decent amount, typical for these types of restaurants for a meal to be at least $12-16; no bev too.

Ronald N.
Ronald N.

My wife and I were shopping around Madison and decided we wanted carry out sandwiches for lunch. We called our order and were advised it would be ready in 10 minutes. We arrived about 10 minutes later and were served quickly. Person who served us was friendly and they appeared busy. Small areas for inside and outside seating, so mainly carry out. We ordered a spicy chicken panini and an Italian panini which we shared. Both were large and delicious and came with whole dill pickles. Glad we didn't go with a chain store. Will definitely be back.

Lauren U.
Lauren U.

Crostini has become a go-to for a quick lunch pickup order. Their menu has a lot of variety so I can find whatever I'm in the mood for. Recently I've tried the pepperjack chicken, the brisket reuben, and the farmer's market panini. Once in a while they're a touch greasy but it usually just adds to the flavor. :) I give Crostini a quick call and the sandwich is usually ready in 5-10 minutes! They've really saved me a couple times when I forgot that I didn't really have anything ready to go during a busy work from home day. I've yet to try their pizza, but also good to know: They have chips, cake, and more.

Location

Welcome to the vibrant world of Crostini Sandwiches, a culinary gem nestled in Madison, Wisconsin, at 231 North St. Specializing in a delightful array of gluten-free sandwiches and salads, Crostini brings a fresh twist to the casual dining scene. With its inviting atmosphere and a menu loaded with delicious options, this eatery stands out as the perfect spot for lunch or dinner.

As you step inside Crostini Sandwiches, you're welcomed by a cozy ambiance that balances a casual yet classy vibe. The outdoor seating options provide a pleasant dining experience, whether you prefer enjoying your meal in the sun or snuggled under covered outdoor seating. Accessibility is a key aspect here, with wheelchair access and gender-neutral restrooms, ensuring everyone feels at home.

What truly sets Crostini apart are its sandwiches. Renowned for their generous portions and rich flavors, the menu boasts crowd-pleasers like the Philly Cheesesteak—loaded with your choice of steak or chicken, roasted peppers, and mushrooms, all melted together in gooey mozzarella. If you’re in the mood for something classic, the Classic Cheeseburger featuring a 1/3 lb. patty topped with grilled onions and cheddar cheese, never disappoints. Each sandwich is crafted with care, making it an experience that tantalizes the taste buds.

The reviews tell a story of satisfied customers—from Patti T. praising the online ordering system and the quality of fries to Nancy D. raving about her beloved Italian beef. Don W. and Ronald N. highlight the friendly service and the generous portions that make every visit special. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or planning a gathering with friends, Crostini has got you covered with its excellent catering options and delicious dishes.

In terms of convenience, the restaurant offers delivery and takeout services, making it easy to enjoy your favorite sandwiches at home or on the go. Plus, there’s no need to worry about parking, as street parking is readily available nearby.

  • Highlights of Crostini Sandwiches:
  • Casual and classy atmosphere with outdoor seating.
  • Wide selection of gluten-free sandwiches and delicious salads.
  • Friendly and attentive service, making every meal memorable.
  • Great options for kids and ideal for group gatherings.

In conclusion, Crostini Sandwiches not only satisfies your hunger with its tempting menu but also creates a warm dining experience that keeps you coming back for more. Whether you’re stopping by for a hearty sandwich or indulging in a side of their famous fries, this restaurant is truly a treasure on Madison’s North Side. Visit them today and taste the difference!

For inquiries, reach them at (608) 241-4284 and discover why Crostini Sandwiches deserves a spot on your must-try list!